It Is Comparative Religion, Just Lacking Neutrality
Shimania: salam elfie. minishorts asks if u reads her blog.
menj1980: err…nope. why ?
Shimania: she said her latest post u shd read woh. or something like that…
menj1980: hmm..ok.. hmmm…
Shimania: cam ner ?
menj1980: i dont read her blog anyway. so big deal. thats not going to stop me from discussing religions comparatively.
Shimania: that’s not her point. her point being, u dont have the neutrality in discussing religions comparatively. u can still go on, but ur views are biased.
menj1980: that is only her opinion.
Shimania: ok i share her opinion
menj1980: remember i aim to defend islam from the attacks. i’ve been in the “business” (if you want to call it that) for 8 years running.
Shimania: because while ppl discuss religions from a neutral perspective, u discuss from a extreme islamic perspective. so ur conclusions will always be, err… lopsided.
menj1980: btw give some examples where i dont show “neutrality”.
Shimania: we can ask readers to decide…
menj1980: excluding ayah pin posts…i wasnt trying to be “neutral” there.
Shimania: yeah u wanna defend islam then call it defending islam, not discussing religions neutrally… u lack neutrality when u already sided with one.
menj1980: its still under the subject of “comparative religions”. and i try to be much more factual than Haryn Yahya
Shimania: it’s like SPR calling itself neutral in helping Umno to ganggu Pas.
menj1980: heh, not the same.
Shimania: i think u better change the “comparative religions without neutrality” to “membidas non-muslim religions”
menj1980: heh. i dont “membidas non-muslim religions”.
Shimania: that’s what you have been doing all the while, also, membidas non-extremist muslims
menj1980: or at least not before they “bidas” islam first… if ur talking about tarik taik guy and dunia druid, then i stood by what i said. i wont change it.
Shimania: nobody can change u. but more and more ppl have noticed that you cannot discuss things neutrally, thus, ur arguments lack authority.
menj1980: thats up to the readers to decide…
So my dear readers, can you give me some instances where Rajan Seri Elfiefuddin has strayed away from her neutrality ? Just a few okay, I don’t wish this space to be blown up by his unneutrality, thank you












